The Detroit Lions’ attempt at a fake punt against the Philadelphia Eagles didn’t succeed, prompting questions about why they would try it against such a strong defensive unit.

Coach Dan Campbell explained that the team thought the situation offered a favorable opportunity, but linebacker Grant Stuard noted that the Eagles had clearly prepared for the possibility.

Special teams coordinator Dave Fipp addressed why the play made sense despite the Eagles’ powerful defensive front. “It might not seem ideal, but sometimes the plays that look risky can work. Throughout NFL history, there have been moments when defenses are caught off guard simply because they don’t expect the ball to be run in those situations,” Fipp said. He elaborated that punt units often assume a normal punt, so a sudden fake can gain ground before defenders react.

Fipp also acknowledged that the execution could have been better. “Our blocking could have been improved, and I could have coached the technique more effectively,” he admitted. “On the right side, it was tough, and on the left, they got low on us, making it challenging.”

The Lions’ reputation for aggressive playcalling has made opposing teams more alert, and the Eagles responded differently than past film had suggested. Fipp noted, “They were aware that we’re aggressive, so they adjusted slightly, which is fair. Ultimately, we just needed to execute better.”