With the NFL trade deadline approaching, analysts and former executives are speculating about bold moves teams might make to enhance their rosters. A recent trade proposal has captured the attention of Detroit Lions fans due to its ambitious nature and high cost. Former NFL general manager Mike Tannenbaum has suggested a major trade that would bring star pass rusher Myles Garrett from the Cleveland Browns to Detroit.

Tannenbaum’s proposal requires the Lions to give up a significant package for Garrett. The details indicate that Detroit would acquire Garrett, one of the league’s elite defensive players, in exchange for three first-round picks, a second-round pick, and standout running back Jahmyr Gibbs.

The Trade Proposal: A Major Commitment

Here’s Tannenbaum’s full trade suggestion:

Detroit Lions receive: DE Myles Garrett

Cleveland Browns receive: Three first-round picks, a second-round pick, and RB Jahmyr Gibbs

This potential trade has ignited vigorous debate among fans and analysts. For Detroit, it would represent a substantial investment in their defense, adding a premier pass rusher to a team currently facing injuries along the defensive line. Garrett, a three-time Pro Bowler and one of the top pass rushers in the NFL, could immediately enhance Detroit’s defense, boosting their chances for a deep playoff run.

However, the price is steep. Parting with three first-round picks would significantly deplete the Lions’ future draft resources, limiting their flexibility for roster building in the coming years. Including Jahmyr Gibbs—an exceptionally talented running back—further complicates the deal.

Why Tannenbaum Believes It’s Logical

Known for his bold proposals, Tannenbaum believes the Lions are only a few key pieces away from becoming Super Bowl contenders. He argues that acquiring Garrett would strengthen Detroit’s defense, particularly with Aidan Hutchinson likely sidelined for the season. Garrett’s presence would provide an immediate boost to the pass rush, improving their Super Bowl aspirations.

Tannenbaum asserts that the Lions are in a prime position to win now, and adding a star like Garrett could give them an edge against top teams, including the reigning champion Kansas City Chiefs. However, he acknowledges the substantial cost, suggesting the Lions must evaluate if they are prepared to sacrifice future assets for a “win-now” mentality.

Fan Response: Is the Trade Justified?

Tannenbaum’s proposal has elicited mixed reactions. Some Lions fans are thrilled by the idea of bolstering their defense, while others are cautious about relinquishing so much draft capital, particularly in light of Detroit’s recent drafting success under GM Brad Holmes. Losing Gibbs, a promising young player, would be particularly challenging.

Furthermore, the Lions aim to build a sustainable team with depth and youth, and sacrificing future assets could be seen as a risky move that might not pay off in the long run.

Conclusion: An Unlikely Yet Compelling Trade

While the prospect of acquiring Myles Garrett is certainly appealing for Lions fans, Tannenbaum’s proposed trade appears excessive. Detroit’s front office has been methodical and strategic, favoring draft picks and young talent over high-profile acquisitions. Trading three first-round picks, a second-round pick, and a player like Gibbs might simply be too great a sacrifice—even for someone of Garrett’s caliber.

As the trade deadline approaches, it will be intriguing to see if the Lions pursue any moves to strengthen their roster. For now, fans can debate whether an all-in trade for Myles Garrett would be worth the cost or if Detroit should remain focused on long-term success.