The Cleveland Browns recently revealed why they passed on hiring Dan Campbell as their head coach in 2019. According to reports, owner Jimmy Haslam was not sold on Campbell’s coaching philosophy, particularly his emphasis on building a tough, run-first team ¹.

Campbell’s Interview with the Browns

Campbell, then the tight ends coach for the New Orleans Saints, interviewed with the Browns in January 2019. The team was coming off a winless season and was searching for their fifth different head coach since 2011. Campbell’s interview reportedly went well, with sources suggesting he “knocked it out of the park.” However, Haslam was unimpressed by Campbell’s commitment to running the ball and building a tough team ¹ ².

Haslam’s Concerns

Haslam’s concerns about Campbell’s philosophy likely stemmed from the team’s analytics-driven approach. The Browns’ owner seemed to prioritize passing over running, which conflicted with Campbell’s coaching style. Campbell’s approach would have involved a more balanced offense with a strong emphasis on running the ball, which didn’t align with Haslam’s vision ².

Impact on the Browns

The Browns ultimately hired Freddie Kitchens, who was promoted from within the organization. However, Kitchens’ tenure was short-lived, and he was replaced by Kevin Stefanski in 2020. While Stefanski has had some success with the team, the Browns have yet to find consistency and have not appeared in a Super Bowl since 2006 ¹.

Campbell’s Success with the Lions

Meanwhile, Campbell has found success with the Detroit Lions. After being hired in 2021, he led the team to their first division title since 1993 and a deep playoff run. Campbell’s team has become known for its physical, tough style of play, which has resonated with fans and players alike. The Lions’ success under Campbell is a stark contrast to the Browns’ struggles, making one wonder what could have been if the Browns had hired him ³ ².

Conclusion

The Browns’ decision to pass on Dan Campbell has been widely second-guessed, and it’s hard to argue with the results. While Campbell’s coaching style may not have fit the team’s vision, it’s clear that he has been successful in Detroit. The Browns, on the other hand, continue to search for a head coach who can lead them to sustained success ¹.