The Detroit Lions entered the 2025 offseason with hopes of building on recent success, but not every free agency move delivered the expected results. While some signings provided value, others failed to pay off — making it fair to ask:
What was the Lions’ worst free agent signing of 2025?
Lions’ Best Moves Weren’t Enough
Earlier this week, we highlighted Detroit’s best free agent additions from last offseason. Defensive tackle Roy Lopez and cornerback Rock Ya-Sin stood out as low-cost signings who delivered solid on-field production.
Those types of bargain deals often define a strong offseason. However, even with Lopez and Ya-Sin contributing, the Lions still fell short of a playoff berth, exposing other roster decisions that didn’t work out.
Worst Signing by Default: D.J. Reed
When evaluating Detroit’s free agent class, the most disappointing signing appears to be D.J. Reed.
Reed remains a talented defensive back, and there is optimism that he can rebound in 2026. But after an injury-plagued 2025 season and a difficult finish to the year, his three-year, $48 million contract has not justified its value so far.
The situation looks worse when compared to the player he replaced. Former Lions cornerback Carlton Davis enjoyed a strong season with the New England Patriots, finishing 18th among all NFL cornerbacks in Pro Football Focus grade (74.0).
While Reed’s struggles weren’t entirely his fault, the return on investment simply hasn’t been there yet.
Other Regrets From the 2025 Offseason
If the discussion included moves Detroit didn’t make, the Lions’ failure to prepare for Frank Ragnow’s retirement would rank high. The team also missed an opportunity to upgrade at edge rusher, either by re-signing Marcus Davenport or pursuing an outside free agent.
Still, because Detroit took a conservative approach in free agency, there were few truly disastrous signings.
Final Verdict
The Lions’ worst free agent signing of 2025 wasn’t catastrophic — but by default, D.J. Reed’s contract stands out as the least successful move so far. With better health and improved play in 2026, Reed still has time to change that narrative.
