Will the Cowboys Dismiss Mike McCarthy? Why the Struggling Coach is Under Pressure After a 1-2 Start
Mike McCarthy has improved his regular-season success with the Cowboys, but his playoff record in Dallas stands at 1-3, contrasting with his 10-8 playoff record and Super Bowl victory during his time in Green Bay.
Several factors contribute to the Cowboys’ struggles in the postseason, including inconsistent performances from quarterback Dak Prescott.
Despite this, Prescott recently received a substantial long-term contract, while McCarthy’s deal only extends through this season.
To secure his position, McCarthy must lead the Cowboys to the playoffs and achieve better results there.
However, he could face dismissal sooner if it becomes clear that the team is unlikely to make the playoffs.
Following a loss to the Ravens, which dropped the Cowboys to 1-2, speculation about his job security is intensifying.
Fortunately for McCarthy, the Cowboys have a chance to bounce back with a Thursday night matchup against the Giants in Week 4.
However, they should not underestimate the Giants, who just secured a win against the Browns.
Achieving a .500 record is crucial, but the following weeks present a tough challenge with games against the Steelers, Lions, 49ers, and Falcons, leading up to their Week 7 bye.
It’s plausible that the Cowboys may win only one of those contests, potentially leaving them at 3-5 midway through the season, which would match their loss totals from the previous three years.
If owner Jerry Jones considers parting ways with McCarthy during the season, he might look to promote defensive coordinator Mike Zimmer, a former Vikings head coach, as an interim solution. Following that, Jones could pursue a high-profile coaching replacement, aiming to end the team’s Super Bowl drought.
At this point in the season, with the Cowboys sitting at 1-2, rumors about potential candidates for McCarthy’s successor are likely to circulate. Bill Belichick, the former Patriots coach, could be a name mentioned.
Additionally, considering a focus on youth and offense, strong candidates like Lions offensive coordinator Ben Johnson and Falcons offensive coordinator Zac Robinson may come into play.
While McCarthy has seen some success with the Cowboys, the current season could quickly turn sour if the team doesn’t improve.