Why Jordan Montgomery Might Be the Next Pitching Turnaround in New York

As the New York Mets prepare for the 2025 season, they are on the lookout for opportunities to strengthen their rotation without breaking the bank. One such opportunity may come from an underperforming Arizona Diamondbacks pitcher, Jordan Montgomery, whose costly contract has left the Diamondbacks eager to move on. But for the Mets, Montgomery represents the potential for yet another pitching reclamation project, a role they’ve successfully filled in recent years.

A Struggling Arm in Arizona

Jordan Montgomery’s recent stint with the Diamondbacks has been far from what the organization expected. After signing him to a $50 million contract, Arizona hoped Montgomery would be a reliable piece of their rotation. Instead, the left-hander posted a dismal 6.23 ERA last season, the worst of his career in a full season. It’s no surprise that even the Diamondbacks’ front office has reportedly admitted that signing Montgomery was a mistake.

Faced with the burden of an underperforming pitcher on a hefty contract, the Diamondbacks are exploring trade options. As Bleacher Report’s Zachary Rymer recently noted, a trade might be the best solution for both parties. “Rather than keeping the 31-year-old, the best thing for everyone would be a trade that would give him a fresh start elsewhere. The D-backs would presumably have to eat some of his 2025 salary to facilitate a deal, but likely not the entire sum,” Rymer wrote.

Why the Mets Could Be the Perfect Destination

For the Mets, taking on a struggling pitcher like Montgomery is not without precedent. In recent seasons, New York has become known for its ability to revive the careers of faltering arms. Pitchers like Luis Severino and Sean Manaea, who once looked to be past their prime, found new life with the Mets, posting impressive numbers after a few rough seasons. With the right coaching and adjustments, Montgomery could be next in line for a resurgence in Queens.

Montgomery’s struggles are certainly concerning, but his track record shows promise. Prior to his rough 2024 campaign, the 31-year-old posted sub-4.00 ERAs for three consecutive seasons. His half-season stint with the Texas Rangers in 2023 was particularly notable, where he played a crucial role in helping the team win the World Series. A change of scenery and the Mets’ proven ability to turn pitchers around could be exactly what Montgomery needs to get back to his previous form.

Potential Trade Package

A deal between the Mets and Diamondbacks could hinge on Arizona’s willingness to cover a portion of Montgomery’s salary. Assuming Arizona agrees to eat half of Montgomery’s remaining contract, the Mets could acquire him in exchange for a package centered around two prospects: Dom Hamel and Nick Morabito.

Hamel, a 25-year-old right-hander, has shown flashes of brilliance in the minors, though his performance dipped last season with an ERA above 6.00. He has the tools to succeed, particularly with his strong slider, but he may need a fresh start to unlock his potential. Meanwhile, Morabito, a 21-year-old outfielder, excelled in Low-A and High-A last season, showcasing a solid .312 batting average and an impressive 59 stolen bases. His speed and ability to get on base make him an intriguing prospect, despite not being seen as an elite hitter.

A Win-Win for Both Teams

For the Diamondbacks, moving Montgomery would relieve them of a significant financial burden while allowing them to add two promising young players to their system. For the Mets, the acquisition of Montgomery would be a low-risk, high-reward move. If the Mets can work their magic and restore Montgomery to his former glory, they would have an affordable and reliable arm to help solidify their rotation.

Montgomery’s time in Arizona may be coming to an end, but a fresh start in New York could be just what he needs to turn his career around. With the Mets’ recent success in revitalizing pitchers, this trade has the potential to benefit both franchises and give Montgomery a chance to reclaim his status as a dependable starter in the big leagues.