Typically, analysts identify the top offensive coordinators in the NFL by evaluating several factors, such as the effectiveness of their offenses, player development, innovative schemes, and consistency.

Coordinators like Andy Reid (Kansas City Chiefs), Kyle Shanahan (San Francisco 49ers), and Eric Bieniemy (formerly with the Chiefs, now with the Washington Commanders) are frequently mentioned as some of the top candidates due to their high-scoring offenses and impressive play designs.