The Lions’ decision on Ifeatu Melifonwu’s future doesn’t have to be complicated.

From Week 14 through the playoffs of the 2023 season, Melifonwu was a standout on the Detroit Lions’ defense. Over those eight games, he recorded 30 tackles, 5.5 sacks, five tackles for loss, and 11 quarterback pressures. From Week 14 through the Divisional Round, he ranked as Pro Football Focus’ eighth-highest graded safety and generated significant breakout buzz heading into 2024.

However, that anticipated breakout never came close to materializing. A preseason ankle injury—seemingly misjudged by the Lions—sidelined him longer than expected. As he was set to return, a dislocated finger required surgery, putting him back on injured reserve. Including the playoffs, he played only four games in 2024, registering six pressures and one sack.

Melifonwu’s career has been defined by injuries. Even in 2023, when he played all 17 games, a hand injury relegated him to special teams for much of the season. Out of a possible 68 regular-season games, he has appeared in just 37. A third-round pick in 2021, Melifonwu is now a free agent.

Melifonwu’s versatility remains valuable. Head coach Dan Campbell highlighted it when he returned to action in 2024. A college cornerback turned safety with linebacker-like blitzing skills, Melifonwu offers defensive flexibility. Christian Booher of SI.com noted his free agent status and warned the Lions could lose needed depth if they don’t re-sign him.

Jeremy Reisman of Pride of Detroit pointed out that Melifonwu could be re-signed cheaply after his injury-filled season. He described him as “the optimal version of Will Harris,” capable of playing cornerback, nickelback, or either safety spot. Yet, being the “optimal version” of a replaceable player like Harris is not exactly glowing praise.

In his fourth season, Melifonwu embodied the old adage “hurt guy stay hurt,” making it easy for general manager Brad Holmes to part ways with him. His unique skill set might be hard to replace, but finding a more reliable safety for a depth role won’t be.