In the world of baseball, few questions spark as much nostalgia and playful confusion as “Who’s on first?” A question that first gained fame from the iconic comedy duo Abbott and Costello, it’s a timeless joke that many have since used to explore the humorous intricacies of baseball rosters. Recently, sports columnist Ben Hochman of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch sparked an interesting twist on the classic question, aiming to unravel a more current lineup mystery for the St. Louis Cardinals: “Who’s on first?” Hochman’s conclusion? Contreras. But as the debate continues to unfold, fans are left wondering about another key question: “What guy’s on second?”

Hochman’s playful examination of the Cardinals’ 2025 roster has fans scratching their heads as the team continues to evolve. With catcher Willson Contreras now solidly entrenched in the leadoff position at first base, the question of who will take up the second base position for the Cardinals looms large. In a season where player movement, positional changes, and strategy shifts are expected to play pivotal roles, fans are eager to know how the team’s lineup will ultimately come together.

In the latest spring training games, Contreras has made his debut as a full-time first baseman. While he’s no stranger to the position, having filled in during injuries last season, his shift to first has sparked much chatter. The veteran catcher’s defensive adaptability will be tested, as he looks to transition from behind the plate to a more traditional infield role. The decision was made as part of the Cardinals’ plan to maximize roster flexibility, allowing Contreras to provide a bigger presence offensively while also freeing up more space for younger talent to shine in the catching role.

But even more intriguing than the “who’s on first” question is the uncertainty surrounding second base. Several candidates are in the mix for the spot, with versatile infielder Tommy Edman considered the most likely option, though the situation is still fluid. Edman, a former Gold Glove winner, has the defensive chops for the job but will need to balance offensive consistency to secure the starting role. Meanwhile, rookie prospect Jordan Walker, who has impressed early in camp, could also factor into the team’s decision-making.

Hochman’s musings on these lineup changes serve as a lighthearted exploration of the Cardinals’ evolving team dynamics. However, beyond the fun of the “Who’s on first?” question, it also highlights how the team is making strategic decisions with an eye on both long-term success and flexibility.

As the season progresses, fans will continue to watch how the roster shakes out—especially at second base. Will Edman claim the job, or will someone else step into the role? In true baseball fashion, the answer remains to be seen. For now, one thing is clear: the Cardinals are ready for the season ahead, regardless of who occupies what base.