Sure, TeSlaa offers impressive athletic traits, size, and that underdog drive from a smaller program. But in my opinion, Brad Holmes’ biggest misstep of the 2025 NFL Draft was not holding onto pick No. 102 and selecting Elic Ayomanor—the tough, smart, and proven wideout from Stanford.

Ayomanor wasn’t just an option—many believed he was the obvious selection Detroit should have made in that spot.

For context: Dane Brugler ranked Eric Ayomanor as his No. 11 wide receiver with a projected 3rd Round value, while Isaac TeSlaa was his No. 24 receiver with a 5th-6th Round projection.

“While he still needs polish as a technician, Ayomanor presents a challenge to defenders due to his physicality, athleticism, and size. He shows elite body control when tracking the football and adjusting mid-route.

Although his aggressive mindset and finishing still need refinement, his potential is clear. He’s not fully developed, but he offers a big frame, vertical threat ability, and a wide catch radius. His best football is likely ahead of him.”

An Expensive Gamble on Upside?
Here’s the painful part: to move up and select TeSlaa at No. 70, the Lions surrendered pick No. 102 and two third-round picks in 2026 to the Jaguars. While TeSlaa might offer more upside as an athlete, the talent difference between him and Ayomanor today isn’t wide enough to justify the cost.

If Ayomanor ends up outshining TeSlaa—as I believe he will—this move might be remembered as Holmes’ worst draft decision since becoming Detroit’s general manager.

How This Impacts Detroit’s WR Depth
With Amon-Ra St. Brown locked in as the WR1 and hope pinned on Jameson Williams progressing in 2025, the depth behind them is still uncertain. TeSlaa may become an asset in time, but Ayomanor seemed like someone who could contribute right away.

The Lions are clearly banking on TeSlaa’s future growth, but if that development doesn’t come, passing on Ayomanor could be a major regret.

Brad Holmes has largely succeeded in his time leading Detroit’s drafts, but this decision feels like a rare stumble. Ayomanor at 102 would have preserved key draft capital while giving the Lions a gritty, game-ready receiver. Instead, Holmes bet on long-term traits—and may have passed up the safer, smarter play.