Liverpool’s hunt for fresh firepower up front is accelerating, and the latest report from Caught Offside has intensified speculation. Journalist Mark Brus claims internal talks have taken place at Anfield about potentially using Federico Chiesa in a bold exchange deal to secure Alexander Isak’s arrival.
Although nothing concrete has been agreed, this development comes right after Isak’s outspoken criticism of Newcastle United regarding “broken promises.” The Swedish striker appears eager to depart, and Liverpool are closely monitoring how the saga unfolds.
While Newcastle remain determined to hold onto their prized forward, the prospect of a big-name inclusion such as Chiesa might force them to reconsider. With AC Milan, Inter, Napoli, Atalanta, Roma, and Fulham all circling the Italian star, Liverpool would have no difficulty finding interested buyers.
Chiesa, however, has given manager Arne Slot plenty to ponder following his lively cameo in the 4-2 triumph over Bournemouth. His impact off the bench proved decisive, once again highlighting the qualities that once made him a Serie A standout.
Despite the rumours, the winger’s message is firm: he has no desire to leave Anfield during this window. Slot hinted at a rejuvenated Chiesa in his recent press briefing, remarking:
“I now see a completely different Federico than I did for much of last season, which is understandable since he missed the entire pre-season.”
This provides a glimpse into the mindset of both player and coach. After a turbulent start on Merseyside, Chiesa seems more settled and prepared to make a lasting contribution.
It’s also worth stressing Liverpool’s delicate attacking situation, following the summer departures of Darwin Núñez to Al-Hilal and Luis Díaz to Bayern Munich.
At present, the club has only four experienced forwards: Mohamed Salah, Cody Gakpo, Federico Chiesa, and Hugo Ekitike. For a side aiming to retain the Premier League crown and push deep in Europe, that number looks alarmingly short.
Any negotiation involving Chiesa would therefore require an immediate replacement, which is where Isak fits the picture. Yet, given the current shortage, it is hard to see Liverpool parting ways with him unless the incoming deal is swift and strategically sound.
Isak’s dissatisfaction with Newcastle may provide a rare opening. The 25-year-old remains among the league’s most dangerous attackers, and his stance could leave the Magpies in an uncomfortable position.
Even so, persuading them to sell to a direct rival is a major challenge. Including someone of Chiesa’s profile might prove pivotal, though for now it remains a behind-closed-doors idea rather than an imminent transfer.
The story brings equal measures of intrigue and concern. Alexander Isak has the attributes to become a marquee star at Anfield. His technique, finishing ability, and adaptability make him an extremely appealing target.
However, using Chiesa as a trade-off is undeniably risky. His first season had inconsistencies, but recent showings suggest he is finding form under Slot’s guidance. The coach’s public endorsement only strengthens the notion that Chiesa can still thrive in this setup.
With so few recognised forwards available and a demanding calendar ahead, Liverpool cannot afford to weaken one area just to improve another. If a deal for Isak happens, it must avoid sacrificing squad depth.
Isak would indeed be a dream signing, but not at the expense of balance and harmony. Fans will want ambition in the market, yes, but not reckless gambles.
