The Cleveland Browns had the opportunity to hire Dan Campbell as their head coach in 2019 but ultimately decided against it. According to reports, Campbell’s coaching philosophy was a major factor in the decision. Campbell wanted to establish a run-heavy system, which didn’t align with the team’s owner Jimmy Haslam’s analytics-driven approach ¹ ².

The Interview

Campbell, then the tight ends coach with the New Orleans Saints, interviewed with the Browns in January 2019. The interview reportedly went well, with sources describing it as “awesome.” However, Campbell’s emphasis on running the ball and building a tough team didn’t sit well with Haslam, who prefers a more passing-oriented approach ¹.

Haslam’s Influence

Haslam’s influence played a significant role in the decision to pass on Campbell. The owner is said to be a big believer in analytics, which suggests that passing is more important than running. Campbell’s philosophy, which prioritizes running and physicality, was seen as a mismatch with the team’s vision ².

The Aftermath

The Browns ultimately hired Freddie Kitchens as their head coach, who was the team’s interim offensive coordinator at the time. Kitchens’ tenure was short-lived, lasting only 19 games. Meanwhile, Campbell went on to become the head coach of the Detroit Lions, leading the team to consecutive NFC North titles and reviving the career of quarterback Jared Goff ¹.

What Could Have Been

The Browns’ decision to pass on Campbell has been widely debated, with many wondering what could have been if they had hired him. With Baker Mayfield, who was the first overall pick in 2018, and Campbell at the helm, the team might have taken a different path. Instead, the Browns have continued to struggle, cycling through coaches and quarterbacks ³.

Conclusion

The Cleveland Browns’ decision to pass on Dan Campbell in 2019 has proven to be a significant what-if in the team’s history. While it’s impossible to know for certain how things would have turned out, it’s clear that Campbell’s coaching philosophy didn’t align with the team’s vision. As the Browns continue to search for stability and success, they might look back on the Campbell interview as a missed opportunity ⁴.