The One Free Agent Who Makes Perfect Sense if the Lions Lose David Montgomery
The Detroit Lions may be approaching a major shift in their backfield.
If you listened closely to general manager Brad Holmes during his end-of-season press conference, it sounded increasingly possible that David Montgomery has played his final snap in Detroit. Whether due to a trade, release, or salary-cap decision, the Lions appear to be preparing for life after their physical, tone-setting running back.
If Montgomery is on the move, one key question follows:
Who becomes Jahmyr Gibbs’ backfield partner?
One NFL free agent stands out as a near-perfect fit — Tyler Allgeier.
Why the Detroit Lions May Need a David Montgomery Replacement
Montgomery has been the physical heartbeat of Detroit’s rushing attack, thriving between the tackles and finishing drives. However, the Lions may be ready to fully build the offense around Jahmyr Gibbs as the primary playmaker.
That doesn’t mean abandoning power football. Instead, it means finding a younger, more affordable version of Montgomery’s role — a downhill runner who can punish defenses while Gibbs creates explosive plays.
That profile points directly to Allgeier.
Why Tyler Allgeier Is the Best Free-Agent Fit for the Lions
For years, Tyler Allgeier and David Montgomery have drawn comparisons, and for good reason. Their running styles are remarkably similar.
Both backs are:
Physical through contact
Effective between the tackles
Dependable in short-yardage and goal-line situations
During the 2025 NFL season, Allgeier rushed for 514 yards and eight touchdowns on limited carries, proving his value as a red-zone finisher. Earlier in his career, he also demonstrated feature-back ability by eclipsing 1,000 rushing yards in a season.
That versatility makes him an ideal complementary back — and a capable starter if needed.
How Tyler Allgeier and Jahmyr Gibbs Would Complement Each Other
A Gibbs-Allgeier tandem would closely resemble the Lions’ most effective offensive formula:
Jahmyr Gibbs: explosive, versatile, space-creating weapon
Tyler Allgeier: punishing, downhill, drive-finishing force
This pairing would allow Detroit to maintain its physical offensive identity while shifting the focal point toward Gibbs as the engine of the offense.
Final Thoughts
If the Lions move on from David Montgomery, Tyler Allgeier represents one of the smartest free-agent options available. He fits Detroit’s scheme, mirrors Montgomery’s playing style, and provides flexibility without sacrificing toughness.
For a team with Super Bowl aspirations, that kind of balance matters.
